Contents hide
1 God

God

Summary

God is the Father, Jesus Christ the Son, and the Holy Spirit (Titus 3:4-6).

Endorsements

All Christians agree in the Trinity because this is a “core doctrine,” what defines Christians from non-Christians.

Concepts

Trinity

God is the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.

When Christians say we worship God, we believe God is three separate Beings: the Father, Jesus Christ, and the Holy Spirit (Matthew 28:19). These Beings are all God because each is defined as a Savior to humanity (Titus 3:4-6).

God is three in one.

Christianity claims to be a monotheistic religion because God is one (Deuteronomy 6:4; Mark 12:29). We also see that each Person claims divinity: the Father of all (Ephesians 4:6), the Son of God (John 5:18), and the literal Spirit of God (I Thessalonians 4:8). During creation the “elohim” created the world, and “elohim” is the plural form of God; we also see the word “us” was used (Genesis 1:26). The immediate next verse uses “he created,” showing that God can be both plural and singular at the same time (Genesis 1:27).

The Trinity is co-equal.

Co-equal means that the Father, Son, and Spirit are all equally God (Matt 28:19). The Father is God (I Cor 15:24), the Son is God (John 1:1), and the Spirit is God (Acts 5:3-4).

There is subordination in the Trinity.

The Holy Spirit is subordinate to the Father and the Christ (John 16:13), and Jesus Christ is subordinate to the Father (John 12:49). Being “one” is about choosing to have the same beliefs and love (Philippians 2:2), not about knowledge or authority (Luke 2:52). We also agree with the church fathers that subordinationism is false. While there is a subordination through submission of authority, there is not a hierarchical ranking based in their ontological essence. While the Father is greater than the Son (John 14:28), the church fathers believed this greatness is one of necessary Eternal Generation of His divine source to Christ (Heb 2:11), not an act of creation that would necessitate a hierarchy within the Trinity.

Jesus is fully man and fully God.

Also known as the hypostatic union, Jesus was always a man and was always God at the same time (John 1:1,14).

Each member of the Trinity has a different primary purpose.

God the Father’s purpose is to be an example of perfection (Matthew 5:48), distant from sin (Psalms 10:11; Matthew 27:46) and working all things to be in its proper order (I Corinthians 15:28). The purpose of the Son of God is to be Creator (John 1:3), Savior (II Timothy 1:10), and Lord (Matthew 7:21). The purpose of the Holy Spirit is to be a truth Guide (John 16:13) and Helper for righteousness (John 14:26).

FAQ

Filioque

What is the filioque controversy?

In the original Nicene Creed in 381, it says that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father. The Roman Catholic church added that the Holy Spirit also proceeds from the Son in the 6th century to clarify what they felt was obvious. This issue was the primary reason the Eastern Orthodox church split from the Roman Catholic church in the Great Schism of 1054. Both claimed that the other church was a grave heretic and that they alone were the “one true church” of Jesus Christ, but they are both not heretical because they both accept the divinity of the Trinity as 3 Persons in 1. We agree with the Orthodox that the filioque should not have been added.

What are some common terminologies associated with this debate?

  1. Proceeds, Procession (Ekporeuetai, Procedit)
    1. Orthodox–the ultimate origin, source, principle
    2. Catholic–comes forth, is sent from
  2. Temporal Mission–the temporary duties of the Spirit
  3. Eternal Procession–the Spirit’s origin
  4. Filiation–Jesus’ relationship to the Father as Son
  5. Spiration–origin of the Holy Spirit, either from the Son or Father

What do modern denominations teach?

The majority of the eastern denominations, such as the Eastern Orthodox, Oriental Orthodox, and Assyrian Church of the East, reject the filioque. The majority of the western denominations, such as the Catholics, Anglicans, Lutherans, Reformed, and Methodist, affirm the filioque. Practically, the majority of all eastern and western Christians don’t understand the biblical points of the other side and simply agree with their personal tradition (Mark 7:8-9). As for us, we reject the filioque but believe those who believe in it are not heretical.

What are all the different ways to divide on this?

The majority of Christians take the “liberal” view, that this controversy is not a matter of core doctrine, also known as a theologoumenon. Some, especially conservatives in the Eastern Orthodox faith, take the “rigorist” view, that this differentiation means that the western churches teach a fundamentally false faith. Here are some reasons for the liberal view:

  1. Few Texts–The Great Schism was built off a few key verses. If God really wanted the church to divide over this, one can assume He would’ve given at least a paragraph.
  2. Commanded–We are commanded to divide over the fact that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are God, Lord, and Savior, not who the Spirit proceeds from (Tit 3:3-11).
  3. From God–John says that anyone who confesses the incarnation of Christ is from God (I John 4:2-3), which are all major Christian faiths, except for versions like Mormonism.

What aspects of the filioque were grounds for excommunication?

  1. Multiple Ultimate Sources–The Orthodox believed the Catholics thought the Spirit had 2 ultimate sources, breaking the Father being above all, like a monarchy (I Cor 15:28). The Catholics, though, believe the Father is above the Son (John 14:28).
  2. Church’s Authority–The Catholics primarily disliked that the Orthodox denied the authority of the pope, as they claimed their leader had more authority. They still believe this, although all Protestants disagree that either leader holds supreme authority.
  3. Arianism–Catholics were also concerned the Orthodox taught that Jesus was created (Heb 1:5-6). The Orthodox always believed Jesus was not created (Col 1:16).
  4. Hierarchy–The Catholics were concerned that the Orthodox believed that the Son and Holy Spirit had equal ranking, but the Orthodox believe that the Spirit is subordinate to the Son.

Do the Orthodox and Catholic churches still condemn each other?

While they still disagree, they have officially revoked their condemnation of the other organization:

  1. Lifting Excommunication: In 1965, the Catholic Pope Paul VI and the Orthodox Ecumenical Patriarch Athenagoras I formally lifted the mutual excommunications of 1054.
  2. Catholic Acceptance: In 1995, the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity acknowledged the original creed as fully orthodox and legitimate.
  3. 2002 Consultation: In 2002, the 62nd North American Orthodox–Catholic Theological Consultation clarified how both versions of the Nicene Creed can be legitimate if interpreted within their own theological framework, especially the Greek-Latin gap between ekporeusis (Greek; John 15:26) and processio (Latin).

How should John 15:26 be translated?

At first glance, it seems the Orthodox are right because this verse directly says the Spirit “proceeds from the Father,” not mentioning the Son. The Catholics interpret proceeds [ekporeuetai] as “is sent from”; so, considering Jesus said “I will send”, it makes sense that the Spirit proceeds from the Father and Son. Both translations of “proceeds” exist in Scripture: as the source (Mark 7:21; Rev 22:1) and being sent from (Rev 4:5; John 8:42). We believe the Orthodox view makes more sense because the first clause “whom I will send” is about the Spirit’s Temporal Mission while the “who proceeds from the Father” is about the Spirit’s Eternal Procession. It wouldn’t make sense for Jesus to doubly talk about the Spirit’s Temporal Mission.

How should Galatians 4:6 be translated?

The Catholics believe “Spirit of His Son” is proof that the Spirit proceeds from the Son, whereas the Orthodox claim this phrase is talking about the fact that the Spirit’s Temporal Mission is to teach the church about the Son. We believe this phrase is logically ambiguous and that both interpretations are valid. We agree with the Orthodox, though, because that is the context. The Temporal Mission or purpose of the Spirit is to redeem those who are under the law (Gal 4:5). More than context, “Spirit of His Son” does not mean that the Spirit’s origin is the Son, in the same way a person could say “the car of his son,” knowing that the car is actually owned by the son’s father. This same logic applies to Philippians 1:19.

Christology

Is Jesus God?

Yes. If you’re wondering why Jesus never said, “I am God” more directly, it’s because He never praises Himself (Proverbs 27:2), being perfectly humble (Isaiah 57:15; Matthew 11:29). The whole point of faith is to see if we believe Jesus is God or not (I John 4:2-3).

  1. Father’s Claim: The Father claims the Son is God (Heb 1:8).
  2. Oneness: Jesus said He is one with the Father (John 10:30). Being one with God means you are God (John 10:38), which angered the Pharisees (John 10:33; John 5:18) who claimed He was equating Himself to God (John 5:18).
  3. I AM: He also said “I AM”, another claim of being God (John 8:58-59; Exodus 3:14).
  4. Followers: All of Jesus’ followers also thought He was God (John 1:1-2,14,17; John 20:28), including the early church.
  5. Plural Creators: More than that, Jesus is the Creator (John 1:3; Hebrews 1:2), because although God is one, God is also plural because God said “us” in Genesis 1:26.

Was Jesus created?

No. Also known as Arianism, some believe Jesus was created because sons are born, and Jesus is the Son of God (Hebrews 1:5-6). While it’s true Jesus’ source is the Father (Hebrews 2:11), Jesus was not created by the Father. Jesus was always with God and was always God (John 1:1). All things were created by Jesus (Colossians 1:16). Also, the Father calls Jesus “God” (Hebrews 1:8). Origen uses the concept of Eternal Generation, that the Son was eternally begotten by the Father. An analogy would be the Father being the sun, and the Son being the light rays. You cannot have the sun without the light rays. This Eternal Generation is not an act of creation but a necessity of God’s nature.

Did Jesus switch between His divine and human natures (Matthew 3:16)?

Also known as Apollinarianism, some claim Jesus switches between His divine and human nature (John 14:10). Logically, it is possible for the Spirit of God to rest on Jesus and for the Father to be in Him while still being God Himself, because God is all-powerful. The problem with this belief is that the redemption from the New Covenant (Hebrews 9:15) must involve the death (Hebrews 9:16) of the Person who made the Old Covenant (Hebrews 9:17). The only way Jesus’ sacrifice on the cross could save us is if He personally made the Old Covenant, and He did (John 1:3).

Is Jesus the Son of God?

Also known as Nestorianism, some claim that the Christ had two separate natures, that of Jesus and that of the Son of God. They claim Jesus the man was not the Son of God. This was the same claim of Satan (Matthew 4:3). While it’s true Jesus never directly said it, Jesus wanted us to believe He is God and the Son of God (John 3:18). Jesus did indirectly say He was the Son of God as a question (John 10:36). He also refers to Himself as the Son quite often (John 3:36), and never corrected anyone who believed He is the Son of God (John 11:27).

Did Jesus gain His divinity during His baptism?

Also known as Adoptionism, some claim Jesus was only a man before the Holy Spirit descended on Him (Matthew 3:16), and He gained divinity by being sinless. The Bible says that Jesus was “begotten” (Hebrews 1:5) and a human that is begotten by definition can’t be adopted.

Was Jesus more divine than human?

Monophysitism teaches that Jesus was only divine, not having a human nature. Eutychianism teaches that Jesus’ divine nature overpowered his human nature to where He was basically only divine. The reason why Jesus’ humanity is important is because through His suffering as a human, He was made into our perfect High Priest, because we can now relate to Him as a Being who was tempted (Hebrews 2:10; 4:15). If Jesus didn’t have a human nature or it was so overpowered by His divine nature, then He wouldn’t have suffered while being tempted.

Was Jesus only appearing to have an earthly body?

Also known as Docetism, some claim that Jesus only appeared to have a real body, but in reality was only spiritual (Matthew 5:26). There are many examples of Jesus eating (Luke 24:43). We are also warned to believe that Jesus Christ came from heaven into a fleshly body (I John 4:2-3).

Did Jesus have His own will separate from the Father?

Also known as Monothelitism, some claim Jesus didn’t actually have a human will. Most Christians believe in dyothelitism, that Jesus had a human will and a divine will. While it’s true that Jesus wanted to do the Father’s will (John 5:30), Jesus claimed to have His own will (Luke 22:42). We agree with the Third Council of Constantinople that Jesus Christ has 2 energies and 2 wills because He is fully man and fully God through the hypostatic union.

How can Jesus be God if He talked with God?

Some claim Jesus isn’t God because He talked to God (John 17:1). Jesus claimed to be one with God (John 17:22). Being “one” is about choosing to have the same beliefs and love (Philippians 2:2), not about knowledge or power (Luke 2:52).

How can Jesus be God if He doesn’t know everything (Matthew 24:24,36)?

Jesus was once a child who needed to grow in wisdom like any human (Luke 2:46,52) and be taught by the Father (John 8:28). When Jesus claimed to be one with the Father (John 10:30,38), this oneness is not having the same thoughts, as most Christians believe the Trinity is 3 distinct Persons, who have their own minds and have ranking (John 14:28). Although the Father knows everything (I John 3:20) and Jesus was perfected through suffering (Hebrews 2:10), the reason Jesus is God is that while the universe and us humans are created by Jesus (John 1:3), Jesus was not created by the Father but existed with Him (John 1:1-2). Being perfect or God is not about knowledge but about having a divine nature that has full control over sin (Hebrews 4:15).

Did Jesus remove His divine nature during incarnation?

No. Also known as kenoticism, some believe the emptying in Philippians 2:7 means that Jesus removed His divine nature and powers to only take the form of the servant of being human. This would mean that Jesus was not God for a time. He was always God because:

  1. Humility: The previous verse clarifies that what He emptied was the consideration of being God, not the reality (Phil 2:6). The context of Philippians 2:2-4 is one of humility; the goal is to have this same mindset (Phil 2:5).
  2. Home: All of Jesus’ hometown did not know Him to be God (Mark 6:3); yet, Mary seemed to know of Jesus’ power, likely from His youth (John 2:3-5).
  3. Void: The Greek translation of “emptied” is better translated as “made void” (ekenōsen; Rom 4:14). Even though He was God, He temporarily voided this right to fully understand humanity (Heb 4:15).

Did Jesus inherit a sinful nature?

No. Both sides of this debate agree Jesus never sinned (Heb 4:15) and also had no ability to sin (Heb 6:18; see impeccability). We agree with all of the early church fathers that Jesus never had a sinful nature:

  1. Last Adam: If the first man was born without a sinful nature, it follows the “last Adam” does too (I Cor 15:45).
  2. Pre-purification: For Jesus to be born without the sin nature, many believe Mary was purified before conception.
  3. No Contradiction: If Jesus had a sinful nature that desired evil (concupiscence), even without sin, He’d be rebelling against Himself (Rom 3:10-12).
  4. Self-salvation: If Jesus had a sin nature, He would need saving, too. Even a non-sinner wouldn’t want to live forever with a sin nature.
  5. Temptation: Some think that Jesus’ temptations wouldn’t be real if He didn’t have a sin nature, but Adam was tempted and failed.
  6. Post-lapsarian: It’s unlikely that Jesus inherited a sin nature but perfectly sanctified it before birth. Even if He did, this wouldn’t lead to feeling the sinful nature’s temptation.
  7. Assumption: Jesus needed to assume every aspect of humanity: body, mind, and soul. The sin nature is a defect on man, not his base nature.
  8. Blemishes: The only reason humans can be without blemish (Phil 2:15) is because Jesus’ sacrifice had no blemish, either sin or a sin nature (Heb 9:14).
  9. Seminal Headship: Sin isn’t passed through sperm (Rom 5:12) because God cursed Eve (I Tim 2:14) and the spiritual is not tied to the physical (I Cor 15:44).
  10. Glory: While some say it’s more glorious to heal a broken nature, most believe it’s more glorious to never have had the broken nature, just like the Father.

Was it possible for Jesus to sin?

Also known as impeccability, we believe that it was impossible for Jesus to sin (Heb 6:18).

Trinity

Is the Trinity different forms of the same Being?

Also known as sabellianism or modalism, some take monotheism to mean that Jesus was literally the same, exact Being as the Father. The Father manifested Himself in different modes, but They are actually the same Being. The proponents claim any semblance of differentiation was just an act to show us humans how to relate to God. We see Jesus praying to the Father by Himself, which would have no purpose if Jesus was the same Being as the Father (John 17:1). The reason the Trinity is greater than modalism is because unity is a virtue (Ephesians 4:13).

Who is greater: The Son or Spirit?

Although the Trinity is co-equally God (Matt 28:19), we know the Father is greater than the Son (John 14:28); so, the implication is that either the Son or Spirit is greater than the other. We know that the one who sends is greater than the one who is sent (John 13:16) and that Jesus sends the Holy Spirit (John 15:26; 16:7). Therefore, Jesus Christ is greater than the Holy Spirit, but they are both still co-equally God (Matt 28:19). Greatness is not about sinlessness or power but about rank and authority (John 8:28; 12:49).